In a farewell speech that sparked both debate and reflection, retired
Justice Chiitaranjan Das
of the Calcutta High Court stirred controversy by openly acknowledging his roots in the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS). Das, whose association with the
right-wing organization
dates back decades, emphasized the significance of recognizing one's foundational influences, even as he advocated for a cooling-off period for judges considering a plunge into politics post-retirement.
Addressing attendees at his retirement celebration, Justice Das candidly expressed gratitude towards those who shaped his journey, including the RSS. "It would have been hypocrisy if I had not acknowledged my foundation," he remarked, highlighting the pivotal role the organization played in his formative years.
Clarifying his impromptu remarks, Justice Das emphasized the spontaneity and sincerity behind his acknowledgment of the RSS. "God led me to speak on RSS. It's my root, though I've been estranged from it for 37 years," he said, dismissing any suggestion of insincerity in his tribute.
Drawing parallels to the legendary Justice Krishna Iyer, known for his affiliation with the Communist party, Das challenged the notion that personal ideologies inherently sway judicial decisions. "Was Justice Iyer influenced by Communist philosophy in his judgments? I haven't seen anyone equal to him," Das said, underscoring the autonomy and integrity of judicial reasoning.
While extolling the virtues he imbibed from the RSS, Das refuted claims of indoctrination, contending that the organization fosters character development rather than ideological conformity among youth. "RSS has taught me many good qualities. Children are taught to enrich their personalities, fostering independence of thought," he affirmed, defending the organization against accusations of ideological coercion.
However, juxtaposed against his advocacy for
judicial independence
, Das cautioned against the immediate transition of judges into political roles upon retirement. Citing
ethical considerations
, he advocated for a mandatory cooling-off period of at least two years to safeguard the integrity of the judiciary. "Joining a political party immediately after retirement goes against our moral code of conduct," Das asserted, urging for a measured approach to
post-retirement engagements
.
Das's farewell address, marked by candid reflections on personal and professional affiliations, has reignited discourse on the intersection of ideology, judicial independence, and post-retirement engagements in India's legal landscape.
English (US) ·